Publication

·

Soil as Infrastructure: The Case for Deep Organic Amendment

Daria Okafor, Raúl Santos

·

Urban Greening Journal

·

14 min

When urban plantings fail, the first suspect is usually the plant list. In our experience, the real cause is almost always the ground beneath it: compacted fill, no organic matter and nowhere for roots or water to go.

The hidden cost of cheap soil

Most landscape budgets put soil at the bottom of the list. Topsoil is thinned, amendment is value-engineered out and trees go into small pits of imported mix surrounded by compacted subgrade. The result is years of replacement planting, irrigation and stunted canopy.

What deep amendment changes

Deep organic amendment means working compost into the soil well below the surface, often 18 to 24 inches deep, and breaking up compaction across the whole planting area rather than just the pit. In our test plots, amended soils held more water after storms, grew roots two to three times deeper and needed far less replacement planting in the first five years.

A shift in budget, not just specification

The case we make to clients is simple: moving a modest share of the planting budget into soil is the highest-return investment in any urban greening program. It pays back in survival rates, stormwater performance and the speed at which a landscape starts to look and work like one.

Studio

18 Marsh Wharf, Third Floor · New York, NY 10013

Currently

Late summer. Seed heads forming on the Newtown Creek marsh.

© 2026 Understory Landscape Studio

Studio

18 Marsh Wharf, Third Floor · New York, NY 10013

Currently

Late summer. Seed heads forming on the Newtown Creek marsh.

© 2026 Understory Landscape Studio

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.